| Lig | Tarih | TD | Maç | TD | ||||
| ABD | 10.11.2024 | Pat Noonan | FC Cincinnati | 0 - 0 | New York City FC | Nick Cushing | ||
| ABD | 3.11.2024 | Nick Cushing | New York City FC | 3 - 1 | FC Cincinnati | Pat Noonan | ||
| ABD | 29.10.2024 | Pat Noonan | FC Cincinnati | 1 - 0 | |
New York City FC | Nick Cushing | |
| ABD | 27.08.2023 | Pat Noonan | FC Cincinnati | 3 - 0 | New York City FC | Nick Cushing | ||
| ABD | 8.09.2022 | Nick Cushing | New York City FC | |
1 - 1 | FC Cincinnati | Pat Noonan | |